And now for the whole reason why I have this blog in the first place:
The Year in Music, 2005. I'm a total dweeb for those music rags like Spin, NME, or even the online snobbery that is Pitchfork, who publish their top 40 lists of albums and singles at the end of each calendar year. I started doing my own list a few years ago for my high school paper. My first list included The Strokes, Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, and Blur. Having said that, it also had spots for John Mayer's Heavier Things and Howard Shore's score to
The Return of the King. I can still feel the wetness behind my ears.
I look at 2005 with mixed feelings right now. Usually I find the best music coming out of the UK and while there were some hi-lites from across the pond, the States seem to have gotten its act together this year. Rejoice: not a nu-metal album in sight... although I did see a Linkin Park documentary being sold in Chapters the other day. It's a coffee table book that explores the taxing process of recording "Meteora"… do with this information what you will.
Before my list though, keep in mind that unlike music mags like Spin, I'm not sent free records. Therefore, I probably haven't heard all the best music published this year. For some reason I haven't looked into Devandra Banhart’s
Cripple Crow, nor have I delved too deeply into Sleater-Kinney's
The Woods. I did buy
Frances the Mute by The Mars Volta though. I haven't listened to it yet, mainly for the sole reason that it scares me. But whatever, we all listen to the same music anyway. We just put different numbers beside the album name at the end of the year, so read on if you want. Here's my addition to the giant floating orb of music criticism.
Top Albums of 200510. ... And You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead – Worlds ApartI’ll get this out of the way right off the bat: shit lyrics. I mean, just fuck-awful gents, what the hell were you thinking? If ever there was a prize for the whiniest, most pretentious, and self-righteous lyrics ever written, these guys wouldn’t even show up to the award ceremony. The album focuses on starting over, rejecting the MTV way of life, and making music an actual art form again. You get the sense that the Trail of Dead hope to be the leaders of this musical revolution, reminding us all how robotic we’ve become (most notably with a painfully obvious portrait of Shakespeare on the inside cover). We’ve all had thoughts like these and have probably been on anti-corporate music rant or two of our own, but an entire album of it set to progressive rock riffs and… erm… Russian folk festival influences, is a bit much. We get it boys, really, we do. So why is this album on here then? Well, fortunately for us, the music side of
Worlds Apart is absolutely thrilling. “Caterwaul”, “Let It Dive”, and “Rest Will Follow” are some this year’s greatest guitar driven tracks, each with their own aggressive, anthemic stance with chord changes that make you want to hit something pretty with a baseball bat. Plus it’s so loud that the lyrics are pretty much covered up anyway. There’s also a suprising amount of melody and beauty too. And they’re from Texas, so… um… yeah… that means something important I guess.
Best Track: Rest Will Follow
9. Broken Social Scene – s/t
This is an album you can pour. The songs fall out of the speakers like water from a tap into a glass pitcher beneath them so you can take it over to your kitchen table, sit down, and pour the contents individually into a set of perfect crystal glasses; delicate, breakable, and made so seamlessly you can’t possible imagine how the individual parts could be separated from each other.
So it’s not
You Forgot It In People 2.0. A lot of people weren’t really sure how to react to it, myself included. But after a good long listen in a vacant library one morning at 1 am, I guess anything will make sense. There’s a lot going on so give it a chance and you’ll find something to latch onto in almost every song. The exuberance and sense of occasion that this album carries with it is infectious once you’ve warmed up to the blips, pitter patters, and downtown Toronto background noise layered over every track. See the band live while you can still pick out who’s the lead singer and where the band stops and audience begins.
Best Track: Ibi Dreams of Pavement (A Better Day)
8. Franz Ferdinand – You Could Have It So Much Better
Franz played this one by the book, but they played it well. It was extremely smart of them to release their second album so much closer to their first one. This way they dodge all the build up and over-hype that killed The Strokes or will most likely claim The Killers if Brandon Flowers doesn’t eat his own head before that.
You Could Have It sounds so much fuller and more confident than their self-titled debut. Nothing is as immediate as "Take Me Out" but the subtle changes in tempo and unique song structures add up to an album that is more challenging (as challenging as four awkward scots can be) than its predecessor. The key cheeky art bands is that it needs to be done with a complete sincerity. Something about comedy taking a very serious mind-set or whatever... point is, Franz Ferdinand have fashioned themselves so that no matter what their schtick, their audience will go along with them, wishing their lives could be as fun as the "do do do" part of lead single "Do You Want To" or as enchanting as "Eleanor Put Your Boots Back On". Trust in this band and, like, all your dreams will come true... or something...
Best Track: The Fallen
7. Oasis – Don’t Believe the Truth
People who know me are now going “Of course.” Actually, one look at the title of this blog will gain the same reaction. Yes, I’m an Oasis fan. Yes I have been an Oasis fan for a very long time, through all their ups and (many) downs. But please, hear me out on this one when I say that this is a good album. But be warned: this is not the Oasis you’re used to. With the exception of “Lyla”, their 6th outing is almost completely devoid of hook filled stadium sing-along’s. Oasis was always accused of wearing their influences a little too obviously on their monobrows, but where the Britpop era Oasis borrowed liberally from The Beatles and The Who, Don’t Believe the Truth sees them… whisper it… go indie. Early Rolling Stones and The Velvet Underground are paraded around on tracks like “Mucky Fingers” and my new favouritest drinking song of life, “The Meaning of Soul”.
Oasis has always thrived on working as a duo because, let’s face it, beyond the Gallagher’s the band is pretty uninteresting (and fuck ugly). This still holds true for Don’t Believe, but the dynamics seem to have changed slightly. Instead of relying solely on the brothers one/two punch of cocky guitarist/cockier singer, many songs were penned by Liam and many tracks are sung by Noel. This is not to say that tension are bickering aren’t still present, because that’s what makes this whole Hindenburgian experiment still exciting to watch. But rather, this album marks a certain equilibrium between the self proclaimed leaders of the band, finally drawing upon their collective energy as a band, not that of a coke’d up lead guitarist. It’s a steep statement, but I’ll say it anyway: this is the album that should have followed
(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?
Best Track: Guess God Thinks I’m Abel
6. Bloc Party – Silent AlarmA lot has been written about Bloc Party this year, the majority of it positive, but I wasn’t always on board simply because, on paper, they look like every other hyped British new-new-wave band unleashed this year. Prior to the release of Silent Alarm, the only song I had heard was “Helicopter” which, while good, enrols them into the Franz Ferdinand School of Dance-Rock Skinny British Guys. And then I got my hands a little track called “Banquet” and everything seemed to change. Sure if you played it up against Franz’s “This Ffire” or The Futureheads’ “Decent Days and Nights” you’d hear similar dual-guitar interplay and quirky vocals, but then the chorus hits and a time bomb planted somewhere under Alex Kapranos’ cheeky sneer goes off: good God man! This song has heart. We were too busy dancing and taking each other out to stop and think about the morning after! And the same feeling continues throughout the rest of the album. Bloc Party have managed to take the angular guitar riff heavy dance rock scene and fuse it with a whole lot of perspective, maturity, and soul that send its songs soaring skyward, far from the dance floor. Don’t believe they’re any different? Try to put “Blue Light” on Kaiser Chief’s Employment and get back to me.
Best Track: Banquet
5. Sigur Ros – Takk…For some reason, this album has been absent from a lot of year end lists. Spin didn’t include it, Pitchfork snubbed it, Exclaim! too, and PopMatters.com was too busy letting Slim Thug into its ranks to acknowledge it ever existed. I have a sneaking suspicion that Sigur Ros is doomed to a life of polar opposites. With each subsequent release since Agaetis Byrjun, each album has been classified as either “happy” or “sad”. Apparently Iceland has only two settings. Three if you count Bjork in which case “creepy” is added to the remote control. I’m not entirely sure why this stigma has imbedded itself within the music listening community, because everything the band does seems to craft such a delicate mixture of happiness, sadness, reflection, redemption, life, death, etc etc and the cow jumped over the moon. With no vocals except a wailing gay Icelandic emo kid, I understand that it’s hard to take much more away from each album except raw, basic emotions. It’s the closest we have right now to “pure music” which is something that even Mozart was trying to figure out. But I think this should be appreciated. Therefore Takk… is their “happy” album but don’t let that colour your blank slate before letting this piece of art fill it in for you, unfolding a story of your own emotional interpretation with each graceful brushstroke.
(Editors note: This writer is not high, gay, or a member or Sigur Ros… which in fact would make him both high and gay. He just likes this album THAT much.)Best Track: Glosoli
4. Antony & the Johnsons – I Am a Bird NowEvery year there is one alternative album that gets name dropped, championed, and ultimately exploited by listeners who wish to latch onto something to let everyone else know they are up on the latest trends. That one alternative record allows listeners to say “Yes, I know what this is, I’m current, aware, and above all else, included.” Last year it was the Arcade Fire’s
Funeral (which is funny because, as my friend Todd pointed out, wasn’t the Arcade Fire this year? Oh the information age we live in). This year, the title goes to 300 lb, cross dressing, Mercury Prize winning, Boy George entertaining ballad pop hero Antony Hegarty and this ten track master-piece. In case you haven’t clued into what this album is about when looking through the track list, observing the cover art, or the passage etched into the CD art, here’s your wake-up call: dude wants to be a lady. But rather than coming across as freaky or laughable, the album somehow manages to cast a stillness over that listener’s hand as they reach for the stop button. The album deals with gender classifications and the desire for a free spirit, far away from all the importance of having a set place on the ground.
Thematically then, the album strikes a chord with not just those who are gender-confused, but people who are questioning their place in general which,
pssst, there are a lot of. And the song structure gives more than enough to latch onto with beautiful sweeping melodies that pull on all the right heart strings at all the right moments.
Best Track: My Lady Story
3. The New Pornographers – Twin CinemaFuck you New Pornographers. You’ve unmasked all of us uber-cool indie kids who pretend like listening to some 300 lb arty friend of a friend play the nose flute in a basement that smells like onions and cheap beer is real music for who we really are: confused kids in old t-shirts who really just want to be happy about pop music for once.
You know you’re listening to a great album when you feel compelled to sing along to the songs on your first listen. Just try and sit still to “Use It” or “Sing Me Spanish Techno”. Going beyond the upbeat pop hooks though, Twin Cinema is at many points downright whimsical. Disney could have used the God-affirming refrain from the “The Bleeding Heart Show” to soundtrack Simba’s return to Pride Rock, and “Streets of Fire” contains male/female vocal interplay that would make Stars wish they were from BC. All in all, it’s smart pop with loads of heart and anthems in spades. If you’ve ever wanted to be so happy about something that you almost start to cry, press play, roll down the windows, and drive a little bit faster.
Best Track: Use It
2. Sufjan Stevens – IllinoisOr, more appropriately titled:
The Only Album That Will Ever Be Written About a Midwestern American State And Be Taken Seriously by a 19 Year Old Kid In Guelph Ontario Who Has Never Been Nor Will Probably Ever Be in Said State. I’m not sure if the contents of this album accurately reflect the state of Illinois. I’ve never been and the current happenings in Illinois aren’t really talked about over coffee with my friends. But according to Mr. Stevens, the living dead live next door, UFO’s dominate the skies, protestors and women go insane for extremely valid reasons, and mass murderers dressed as clowns. I’m not really sure if there are giant predatory wasps in the Palisades. Hell, I don’t even know what or where the Palisades are. But it must be true because never have I ever heard someone sound as sincere as Stevens does over these 22 sprawling tracks. Book me on the next flight to Chicago, Sufjan, you’ve convinced me.
Best Track: Chicago
1. Bright Eyes - I'm Wide Awake, It's MorningI bought this album a few days after it came out back in January. My first reaction to it was to it was "Hrm, that's nice... I wonder when Coldplay's new album is coming out?" The songs seemed too bare, too honest, and too folk to hold any real resonance in the music industry. The lead single after all was "Lua", 4 minutes of Connor Oberst clumsily strumming his nylon-stringed guitar, probably half-drunk.
Isn't it fitting then that it should end up at the top of the heap? Looking at the string of releases and tours slated to happen in 2005, it was pretty safe to say that planet-melting stadium rock would make its return (where it exactly, I'm not quite sure... maybe I was too busy listening to the Lord of the Rings scores at the time). But in the end, things didn't really pan out as such. The most poignant records came from artists like Antony & the Johnsons who won the Mercury Prize for his emotional piano ballads, or Sufjan Stevens who focused on the often over-looked details of America's mid-west. It was a year of little triumphs, only further defined by the let-down of the stadium fillers like U2 or Coldplay.
I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning, in my opinion, embodies this spirit in every false strum, every strained vocal plea for forgiveness.
Scattered across its 10 tracks are some of the most sincere moments of lyrical clarity that I've ever heard. The sheer simplicity of it all is mind boggling, but anyone who’s heard the album will know exactly what I’m talking about. It’s hard to express how perfectly Oberst manages to capture a certain theme or musing on life, love, activism, death, politics, more activism… the list goes on. It’s the kind of realizations you have in the middle of a supermarket checkout line or driving a friend home from God knows where or lying in bed at night, unable to find a pen and paper to write it down, hoping you remember it the next morning. Like the album art hints at, it’s a patchwork of different fabrics, woven together beautifully to create a work of simple, majestic beauty. Sure,
X & Y may ask the big questions.
I'm Wide Awake... answers them.
Best Track: Landlocked Blues